Nutella stuffed chocolate chip cookie, cut in half so the filling shows
Nutella Stuffed Chocolate Chip
CERTIFIED BS FREE SPRING MILLS, PA
STUFFED COOKIES

A Cookie Like No Other

Faster Shipping. Better Ingredients. Better Cookies.
Build a box · from $44.94See the packs

Boxes from $44.94 for 6 cookies. Subscriptions ship free.

HAND MADE IN SPRING MILLS, PA
SHIPPED THE NEXT BUSINESS DAY
AS SEEN ON CBS PITTSBURGH · TALK PITTSBURGH ABC27 · GOOD DAY PA WPSU · KEYSTONE STORIES

Don’t want to pick? We already did.

Four different packs. 6 or 12. Done.

See every pack

  • The Chocolate Chip Pack

    Five chocolate chip cookies of one sort or another, and a Smore.

    The Chocolate Chip Pack

    Five chocolate chip cookies of one sort or another, and a Smore.

    In the 6

    • 2 x Original Chocolate Chip
    • 2 x Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip
    • 1 x Nutella Chocolate Chip
    • 1 x Smore Cookie

    In the 12

    The 12 pack is two of each, so 4 x Original Chocolate Chip, 4 x Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip, 2 x Nutella Chocolate Chip, 2 x Smore Cookie. Doubles on the two everyone orders anyway.

  • The All Chocolate Pack

    Six different chocolate cookies. No doubles in this one.

    The All Chocolate Pack

    Six different chocolate cookies. No doubles in this one.

    In the 6

    • 1 x BBC big beautiful chocolate
    • 1 x Brookie Monster
    • 1 x Dubai Chocolate
    • 1 x Reeses OREO Brownie
    • 1 x Cookie Butter Brownie
    • 1 x Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

    In the 12

    The 12 pack is two of each, so 2 x BBC big beautiful chocolate, 2 x Brookie Monster, 2 x Dubai Chocolate, 2 x Reeses OREO Brownie, 2 x Cookie Butter Brownie, 2 x Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip. If you were going to pick the chocolate one anyway, this is all of them.

  • The Peanut Butter Pack

    Peanut butter first, then the rest of the jar shelf.

    The Peanut Butter Pack

    Peanut butter first, then the rest of the jar shelf.

    In the 6

    • 2 x Ultimate Peanut Butter
    • 1 x Dubai Peanut Butter
    • 1 x Reeses OREO Brownie
    • 1 x Nutella Chocolate Chip
    • 1 x Cookie Butter Brownie

    In the 12

    The 12 pack is two of each, so 4 x Ultimate Peanut Butter, 2 x Dubai Peanut Butter, 2 x Reeses OREO Brownie, 2 x Nutella Chocolate Chip, 2 x Cookie Butter Brownie. Two Ultimate Peanut Butter because one was never going to be enough.

  • The Everything But Chocolate Pack

    Snickerdoodles, fruit and oatmeal. Six cookies, not one of them chocolate.

    The Everything But Chocolate Pack

    Snickerdoodles, fruit and oatmeal. Six cookies, not one of them chocolate.

    In the 6

    • 1 x Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle
    • 1 x Biscoff My Doodle
    • 1 x Strawberry Cheesecake
    • 1 x Lemon Sunshine
    • 1 x Apple Turnover
    • 1 x Oatmeal Cream Pie

    In the 12

    The 12 pack is two of each, so 2 x Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle, 2 x Biscoff My Doodle, 2 x Strawberry Cheesecake, 2 x Lemon Sunshine, 2 x Apple Turnover, 2 x Oatmeal Cream Pie. For the person at the table who always passes on the brownie.
  • See every pack

345 reviews and counting.

  • “Imagine the best chocolate chip cookie you’ve ever had and then stuff it with Nutella. That’s this. So good!!!”

    Cat a. · Nutella Chocolate Chip

    Review from Cat a.

    “Imagine the best chocolate chip cookie you’ve ever had and then stuff it with Nutella. That’s this. So good!!!”

    Cat a. · Nutella Chocolate Chip

  • “These cookies are hands down the best cookies I have ever had. I wasn't sure what to expect because they're so big. I was afraid they'd have a cake-like consistency, but that is NOT the case. They're crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, just like a cookie should be. Every flavor I got was so good and I cannot wait for new flavors!”

    Marcella H. · Verified buyer

    Review from Marcella H.

    “These cookies are hands down the best cookies I have ever had. I wasn't sure what to expect because they're so big. I was afraid they'd have a cake-like consistency, but that is NOT the case. They're crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, just like a cookie should be. Every flavor I got was so good and I cannot wait for new flavors!”

    Marcella H. · Verified buyer

  • “Delicious, Presentable and Huge cookies. Individual cookie could feed two people.”

    William M. · Verified buyer

    Review from William M.

    “Delicious, Presentable and Huge cookies. Individual cookie could feed two people.”

    William M. · Verified buyer

  • “Excellent on all points. Fast delivery, outstanding products, and very reasonably priced.”

    Kyle C. · Verified buyer

    Review from Kyle C.

    “Excellent on all points. Fast delivery, outstanding products, and very reasonably priced.”

    Kyle C. · Verified buyer

  • “I ordered 6 cookies. Six cookies that tasted like heaven and made me have dessert before dinner.”

    LESLIE W. · Verified buyer

    Review from LESLIE W.

    “I ordered 6 cookies. Six cookies that tasted like heaven and made me have dessert before dinner.”

    LESLIE W. · Verified buyer

  • “it was really good, problem is my plan of 1 cookie a day turned into 2 and before i knew it i ate $60 worth of cookies”

    Jared A. · Verified buyer

    Review from Jared A.

    “it was really good, problem is my plan of 1 cookie a day turned into 2 and before i knew it i ate $60 worth of cookies”

    Jared A. · Verified buyer

  • “Cookies are amazing and they even sent me a rubber duck with my package. Will definitely order again!”

    Brittany W. · Verified buyer

    Review from Brittany W.

    “Cookies are amazing and they even sent me a rubber duck with my package. Will definitely order again!”

    Brittany W. · Verified buyer

  • “Best cookies I have ever consumed. The caramel chocolate chip is like nothing I have ever tasted and the blueberry lemon cheesecake was a twenty out of ten. Each cookie is a religious experience, please allow me to confess my sins that I did not know what cookies could taste like until Insideout Cookies.”

    Matthew K. · Verified buyer

    Review from Matthew K.

    “Best cookies I have ever consumed. The caramel chocolate chip is like nothing I have ever tasted and the blueberry lemon cheesecake was a twenty out of ten. Each cookie is a religious experience, please allow me to confess my sins that I did not know what cookies could taste like until Insideout Cookies.”

    Matthew K. · Verified buyer

  • “Love these cookies. And they are HUGE!”

    Carrie B. · Verified buyer

    Review from Carrie B.

    “Love these cookies. And they are HUGE!”

    Carrie B. · Verified buyer

The flavors. cut open for your inspection.

CUTAWAY OR IT DIDN’T HAPPEN
All 23 flavors

  • Original Chocolate Chip

    Original Chocolate Chip

    Inside: no filling. This one is just cookie, done properly.

    The one that started it. Browned butter dough, semi-sweet chips, dark and light chocolate wafers, baked slow so the middle stays soft.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, sugar, Semi-Sweet Chocolate chips (MILK, SOY), butter (MILK),EGG, cocoa butter, molasses, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “The most amazing cookies I have ever tried!! Incredible!! My sister ordered a dozen!!”

      Timothy · Verified buyer
    Add to a box

  • Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

    Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

    Inside: one whole Oreo.

    Our browned butter chocolate chip dough with a whole Oreo hidden in the middle and more Oreo crumbled on top. A whole Oreo. Inside. Yes.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, brown sugar, chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) Oreo Cookie, butter (MILK) ,EGG, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    Add to a box

  • Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle

    Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle

    Inside: cheesecake filling.

    Browned butter snickerdoodle dough rolled in cinnamon sugar, stuffed with a creamy cheesecake filling. It has been on the favorites shelf since the beginning and shows no interest in leaving.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, sugar, butter (MILK), EGG, cream cheese(MILK), corn starch, powdered sugar, vanilla, cream of tartar, cinnamon, aluminum free baking powder, salt

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “Wish I would have gotten more of this flavor!”

      Jessica · Verified buyer
    Add to a box

  • Smore Cookie

    Inside Out Cookie smores stuffed cookie

    Inside: homemade marshmallow fluff.

    A dark brown sugar honey graham cookie with chocolate pieces and milk chocolate chips, stuffed with homemade marshmallow fluff. Marshmallow, molten, no campfire, no smoke in your hair.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, sugar, chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) butter (MILK) ,EGG, Graham Crackers (WHEAT), beef gelatin, corn syrup, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    Add to a box

  • Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

    Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

    Inside: homemade caramel.

    Browned butter dough with roasted pecan pieces and a homemade caramel center. Pecan pie, rebuilt as a cookie.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, PECAN, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, brown sugar, butter (MILK), PECANS, EGG, vanilla extract, aluminum free corn starch, baking powder, salt

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “So very good & enjoyed by the family.”

      Mary · Verified buyer
    • ★★★★★

      “The very bestest cookie ever!!”

      Anita · Verified buyer
    Add to a box

  • Nutella Chocolate Chip

    Nutella Chocolate Chip

    Inside: Nutella.

    Browned butter chocolate chip dough, semi-sweet chips, and a molten Nutella center.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, HAZELNUT, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, brown sugar, semi-sweet chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) butter (MILK), EGG, NUTELLA (HAZELNUT) vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder salt

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “Are this cookie last night with milk bar cereal milk ice cream 5/5 great cookie”

      Anthony · Verified buyer
    Add to a box

  • Ultimate Peanut Butter

    Inside Out Cookie Ultimate Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookie

    Inside: creamy peanut butter.

    Browned butter peanut butter dough mixed with peanut butter chips, stuffed with peanut butter, topped with Nutter Butter pieces. Peanut butter, then more peanut butter, then a crunch on top.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    WHEAT flour, sugar, PEANUT butter wafers, butter(MILK), EGG,PEANUT butter(SOY), vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, brown sugar, Nutter Butter Cookies (WHEAT, SOY).

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “Amazing, huge, delicious cookies! I am so happy with my order!”

      Pam · Verified buyer
    Add to a box

  • Brookie Monster

    Inside Out Cookie brookie monster stuffed cookie

    Inside: a Reese's cup.

    A chocolate chip cookie and a brownie fused into one object, stuffed with a Reese's cup and topped with M&Ms and Oreo crumble. Half brownie, zero manners.

    Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

    Ingredients and allergens

    Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT

    Ingredients

    sugar, chocolate chips (sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, milkfat,SOY lecithin, natural flavor)butter, WHEAT flour, EGG, Reese’s Cup, M&Ms, cocoa powder, molasses,vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

    May also contain

    Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

    Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

    What people said about this one

    • ★★★★★

      “I bought a load of cookies after seeing a content creator review them. This cookie is so rich! Right up my alley! Nice balance between chocolate and peanut better. Can’t wait to try the others!”

      Anthony · Verified buyer
    Add to a box
  • All 23 flavors

It's what's inside that counts

Better Ingredients Make Better Dough
  • 01

    Made with real butter

    (Dairy free doughs aren't made with butter, obviously...)

  • 02

    Unbleached flour

    Clean, no extra BS.

  • 03

    No funny chemicals

    No preservatives.

  • 04

    Hand cracked fresh eggs

    Liquid eggs are gross.

  • 05

    Peanut butter made in house

    Fresh peanuts ground on site.

BAKED IN SPRING MILLS, PENNSYLVANIA

SUBSCRIBE · SKIP, PAUSE, CANCEL ANYTIME

Your flavors. Your schedule. Shipped free.

  • 6 cookies

    The weekday.

    Six cookies, your flavors, on your schedule.

    One-time
    $44.94
    On subscribe
    $39.94 Save $5.00

    Ships free

    Build my 6 · every month
  • 12 cookies

    The freeze.

    Twelve cookies. Eat some now, freeze the rest, pretend you have discipline.

    One-time
    $68.94
    On subscribe
    $58.94 Save $10.00

    Ships free

    Build my 12 · every month
  • 18 cookies

    The household.

    Eighteen cookies. For people who share, and for people who say they share.

    One-time
    $98.94
    On subscribe
    $82.94 Save $16.00

    Ships free

    Build my 18 · every month
  • 24 cookies

    The office.

    Two dozen. The break room goes quiet. You get the credit.

    One-time
    $124.94
    On subscribe
    $99.94 Save $25.00

    Ships free

    Build my 24 · every month

Skip, pause or cancel anytime in your Subscriber HQ. We email you before every charge. Subscriber HQ

Certified BS free

Here's what you won't get:

CERTIFIED BS FREE SPRING MILLS, PA
  • 01

    no influencer nonsense

    Your feed is blasted by influencers who will say anything for a dollar

    What they do. Pay people to say they like them.

    What we do. Let you decide what the best tastes like.

  • 02

    no endless wait

    It's been a week, where are my cookies?

    What they do. Make you wait for days and days.

    What we do. Ship your order the next business day. Order on a Friday and it goes out Monday.

  • 03

    no stacks of sugar

    Store bought candy and frosting piled as high as it will go on mediocre dough

    What they do. Hide ordinary cookie dough under last week's grocery store haul.

    What we do. Put the best stuff we can find inside the best dough you can get. Period.

  • 04

    no crazy prices

    They charge you for the best, but give you meh...

    What they do. Charge unfair prices just because they can.

    What we do. Hand make a big cookie and charge a fair price for it.

  • 05

    no hyped up promises

    They say it's the best thing you ever ate!

    What they do. Make big promises they can't keep, and cut corners on quality to make an extra buck.

    What we do. Our best work, with the best ingredients we can find, prepared by people who care about cookies. And you.

  • 06

    no sub-par packaging

    A crushed box, a cheap unsealed bag, a cookie that tastes like your freezer

    What they do. Stuff half baked stale cookies in a plastic bag.

    What we do. Hand pack fresh cookies in an airtight pouch, in a fun colorful box, shipped to you with care.

Insider tip: they’re better warm.

A 15 second shot of microwave love, or a 6 minute hug from your oven makes the best even better.

15-20 secmicrowave. the fast way.
6-7 minoven at 350. the proper way.
3 monthsfrozen. the patient way.
people were already doing it before we printed it.

“These cookies are so good and even better warm. I love getting them at local events.”

Christy B. · Monthly Cookie Box Subscription

Review from Christy B.

“These cookies are so good and even better warm. I love getting them at local events.”

Christy B. · Monthly Cookie Box Subscription
A chocolate peanut butter stuffed cookie pulled open in one hand, crumbs falling
SEEN IN THE WILD

Watch it get opened.

SOUND OFF. CRUMBS ON.

Other ways in.

  • Nick Freed holding a stack of his stuffed cookies out toward the camera
    RAISING MONEY?

    Nobody wants the wrapping paper.

    Schools, teams, churches, the band trip. Terms are set per group, and you get a real answer the same week.

    Start a fundraiser
  • An open Inside Out Cookie box with the card that comes inside it
    FOR THE PEOPLE FAR AWAY

    Send one as a gift.

    College kid. Deployed spouse. A mom three states away. You write the note and it ships the next business day.

    Build a gift boxGift cards
  • MET US AT A TENT?

    Can’t buy it near you? You can now.

    Found us at an event and went home without a box? The same cookies ship anywhere in the country.

    Ship it to meEvent schedule

The list gets the drops first.

New flavors, the event schedule, and the odd bit of news from the bakery. No spam. We are certified.

You’ll get emails from us when there’s something worth saying. Leave any time with one click. Privacy policy