Inside a Reese’s cup
In any box · from $44.94 for 6
Start a box with this oneOr take a ready-made pack“These cookies were so good and so much better than Crumbl.”
“These cookies were so good and so much better than Crumbl.”
How it gets to you
- Ships the next business day
- Friday orders ship Monday
- Damaged, melted or wrong? Send a photo. We replace it or refund it. Refund policy
15% off the first one.
Join the list. We send the drops first and the odd bit of news from the bakery. No spam. We are certified.
The code is in your inbox. Here it is now:
Once per customer. Applies itself at checkout.
Build my box →About this cookie
A chocolate chip cookie and a brownie fused into one object, stuffed with a Reese's cup and topped with M&Ms and Oreo crumble. Half brownie, zero manners.
Inside it: a Reese's cup.
Heat it: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.
Allergens: every bag carries its ingredient label. If you have a food allergy, email info@insideoutcookie.com before you order and we will tell you exactly what is in this cookie and what else is in the kitchen. We answer fast.
How big. The weight is printed on every label and it changes by flavor, around six ounces on most, five and a half on some, five on three of the gluten friendly ones. These are not the biggest cookies anyone has ever made. They are nowhere near small.
Ingredients and allergensContains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT
Ingredients and allergens
Ingredients
sugar, chocolate chips (sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, milkfat,SOY lecithin, natural flavor)butter, WHEAT flour, EGG, Reese’s Cup, M&Ms, cocoa powder, molasses,vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee
May also contain
Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.
Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.
Heat it
- 15-20 sec microwave. the fast way.
- 6-7 min oven at 350. the proper way.
- 3 months frozen. the patient way.
Every cookie ships with heating instructions in the lid.
Shipping
Every cookie is baked and sealed each day in individual pouches, then snuggled into a custom cookie box for protection. We will ship your order the very next business day, unless you order on a Friday. If something turns up wrong, email info@insideoutcookie.com and we sort it.
- ★★★★★
“These cookies were so good and so much better than Crumbl.”
Mary · Verified buyer - ★★★★★
“I bought a load of cookies after seeing a content creator review them. This cookie is so rich! Right up my alley! Nice balance between chocolate and peanut better. Can’t wait to try the others!”
Anthony · Verified buyer
