Build a box · 6 to 24 cookies

Build your box. Pick every cookie.

Any mix of any flavors you want, or take all of the same one if that's what you're into. Can't decide? Let us pick!

Your box

Skip to your box

Flavors

Apple Turnover

Inside: croissant cookie butter and homemade apple pie filling.

Cookie Butter Brownie

Inside: Biscoff cookie butter.

Lemon Sunshine

Reeses OREO Brownie

Inside: Reese's peanut butter and Oreo pieces.

Dubai Peanut Butter

Inside: crispy peanut butter filling.

+$1 premium flavor

Dubai Chocolate

Inside: homemade pistachio filling with crispy kataifi.

Birthday Cake Funfetti

Inside: cream cheese frosting.

Gluten friendly

Gluten Dairy Friendly Oreo Stuffed Brownie

Inside: a gluten-free Oreo.

Caramel Pumpkin Cheesecake Snickerdoodle

Sold out

Strawberry Cheesecake

Inside: cheesecake filling and house-made strawberry preserves.

Ultimate Peanut Butter

Inside: creamy peanut butter.

+$1 premium flavorSold out

Protein Peanut Butter Stuffed Peanut Butter

Inside: creamy peanut butter.

BBC big beautiful chocolate

Inside: chocolate ganache.

Brookie Monster

Inside: a Reese's cup.

Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

Inside: homemade caramel.

Gluten friendly

Gluten dairy friendly Oreo stuffed chocolate chip

Inside: a gluten-free Oreo.

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

Inside: one whole Oreo.

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Inside: vanilla cream filling.

Smore Cookie

Inside: homemade marshmallow fluff.

Original Chocolate Chip

Inside: no filling. This one is just cookie, done properly.

Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle

Inside: cheesecake filling.

Nutella Chocolate Chip

Inside: Nutella.

What people are saying

  • “I was gifted one of these by someone at work and I was wonderfully surprised by how absolutely delicious this cookie was. Everything was absolutely perfect between the cookie and the filling. My only complaint is that I can't find a way to buy more (in NY) otherwise the best cookie I've ever bought from a store.”

    Tyler C. · Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

    Review from Tyler C.

    “I was gifted one of these by someone at work and I was wonderfully surprised by how absolutely delicious this cookie was. Everything was absolutely perfect between the cookie and the filling. My only complaint is that I can't find a way to buy more (in NY) otherwise the best cookie I've ever bought from a store.”

    Tyler C. · Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

  • “Imagine the best chocolate chip cookie you’ve ever had and then stuff it with Nutella. That’s this. So good!!!”

    Cat a. · Nutella Chocolate Chip

    Review from Cat a.

    “Imagine the best chocolate chip cookie you’ve ever had and then stuff it with Nutella. That’s this. So good!!!”

    Cat a. · Nutella Chocolate Chip

  • “Oh my goodness how has no one written a review about these cookies! They are insanely good! So over the top in the best way possible. The birthday cookie was a fan favorite! I’m writing this review actually because I had to find IOC’s website to order more because my daughter is sobbing that someone took a bite of her cookie! And I get it, I’d be sad too. These are out of this world and I consider somewhat of a cookie connoisseur!”

    Sara · Birthday Cake Funfetti

    Review from Sara

    “Oh my goodness how has no one written a review about these cookies! They are insanely good! So over the top in the best way possible. The birthday cookie was a fan favorite! I’m writing this review actually because I had to find IOC’s website to order more because my daughter is sobbing that someone took a bite of her cookie! And I get it, I’d be sad too. These are out of this world and I consider somewhat of a cookie connoisseur!”

    Sara · Birthday Cake Funfetti

  • “I randomly came across these on Facebook. Love to support small business, thought I’d give them a try. These cookies exceeded my expectations! I ordered each of the cookies for my family and me to have on Christmas. All of them were great. Everyone seemed to have their own favorites. However, I would say my favorites were the blueberry, Nutella, and the chocolate chip. I would recommend these to anyone. Shipping was quick, packaging was great. Thank you!”

    Tucker

    Review from Tucker

    “I randomly came across these on Facebook. Love to support small business, thought I’d give them a try. These cookies exceeded my expectations! I ordered each of the cookies for my family and me to have on Christmas. All of them were great. Everyone seemed to have their own favorites. However, I would say my favorites were the blueberry, Nutella, and the chocolate chip. I would recommend these to anyone. Shipping was quick, packaging was great. Thank you!”

    Tucker

  • “Customer Service was awesome, fast shipping, the cookies are soft,chewy, moist flavors are so good. Would definitely place another order,.Brookie cookie was so good the best of both worlds, s'mores was my second favorite, snickerdoodle with creamcheese center was third, carrot cake with creamcheese center was my fourth favorite. Highly recommend”

    Holly j. · Verified buyer

    Review from Holly j.

    “Customer Service was awesome, fast shipping, the cookies are soft,chewy, moist flavors are so good. Would definitely place another order,.Brookie cookie was so good the best of both worlds, s'mores was my second favorite, snickerdoodle with creamcheese center was third, carrot cake with creamcheese center was my fourth favorite. Highly recommend”

    Holly j. · Verified buyer

  • “There's no such thing as only eating half. Forget your macros or any sense of decency and eat the whole cookie. Every flavor is great. S'mores and snickerdoodle are my favorites but the white chocolate macadamia and walnut brownie are close behind. They do not skimp on the chips or nuts, every cookie has perfect texture. Packaged well, pop them in fridge or freezer then microwave when ready for that fresh baked cookie taste.”

    Reality W. · Verified buyer

    Review from Reality W.

    “There's no such thing as only eating half. Forget your macros or any sense of decency and eat the whole cookie. Every flavor is great. S'mores and snickerdoodle are my favorites but the white chocolate macadamia and walnut brownie are close behind. They do not skimp on the chips or nuts, every cookie has perfect texture. Packaged well, pop them in fridge or freezer then microwave when ready for that fresh baked cookie taste.”

    Reality W. · Verified buyer

  • “I bought this cookie along with the Nutter Monster and both were awesome! (Especially when put in the oven for a few minutes) I wish there was a store here in Orlando so I could pick them up whenever! Keep up the awesome work!”

    Brennan · Verified buyer · Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

    Review from Brennan

    “I bought this cookie along with the Nutter Monster and both were awesome! (Especially when put in the oven for a few minutes) I wish there was a store here in Orlando so I could pick them up whenever! Keep up the awesome work!”

    Brennan · Verified buyer · Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

  • “The best cookies I've ever tasted. When i first saw it at the fridge i thought it was an ordinary cookie. But i got curious so i snatched 1 of it and sneaked it into my room and then boom!!! The cookie exploded to my mouth. Soo yummy and flavorfull.”

    Jou · Nutella Chocolate Chip

    Review from Jou

    “The best cookies I've ever tasted. When i first saw it at the fridge i thought it was an ordinary cookie. But i got curious so i snatched 1 of it and sneaked it into my room and then boom!!! The cookie exploded to my mouth. Soo yummy and flavorfull.”

    Jou · Nutella Chocolate Chip

  • “I loooovvvveeeee it!!!!”

    Patty s. · Dubai Chocolate

    Review from Patty s.

    “I loooovvvveeeee it!!!!”

    Patty s. · Dubai Chocolate

More reviews

Packed and shipped with care

Every cookie is baked and sealed each day in individual pouches, then snuggled into a custom cookie box for protection.

  • Ships the next business day
  • Friday orders ship Monday
  • Damaged, melted or wrong? Send a photo. We replace it or refund it. Refund policy

Questions

When does it ship?

The next business day. Order on a Friday and it goes out Monday.

What if it shows up damaged, melted or wrong?

Email info@insideoutcookie.com as soon as you open the box, with your order number and a photo. We replace it or refund it. The details are in the refund policy.

Can I get six of the same?

Yes. You pick every cookie in the box yourself so you only get what you want. Mix it up or keep them all the same. On subscriptions, swaps go through the form in your Subscriber HQ, so next month's box does not have to look like this month's.

Are the gluten friendly ones gluten-free?

No. They are gluten friendly, not certified gluten-free: they are made in a kitchen that also handles wheat. If that matters for a medical reason, email info@insideoutcookie.com before you order.

Does a subscription cost more to ship?

No. Subscriptions ship free, the first box and every renewal. One-time boxes pay the shipping rate shown at checkout.

How do I cancel a subscription?

From your account: open Subscriptions to skip, pause or cancel. No phone call. The Manage my subscription button in Subscriber HQ goes to the same place, or email info@insideoutcookie.com and we do it for you. We email you before every charge. Full terms

Apple Turnover

Apple Turnover

Inside: croissant cookie butter and homemade apple pie filling.

A snickerdoodle base with a cookie butter made from croissants instead of cookies, double stuffed with our homemade apple pie filling. It tastes like a turnover that gave up on pastry and committed to being a cookie.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Every bag carries its ingredient label. If you have a food allergy, email info@insideoutcookie.com before you order and we will tell you exactly what is in this cookie and what else is in the kitchen. We answer fast.

Cookie Butter Brownie

Cookie Butter Brownie

Inside: Biscoff cookie butter.

Our brownie dough, dialed a shade lighter on the chocolate so the cookie butter gets a word in. Stuffed with real Biscoff cookie butter and topped with Biscoff crumble.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

sugar, butter, WHEAT flour, EGG, Biscoff Cookies, cocoa powder, Biscoff Cookie Butter, molasses,vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Lemon Sunshine

Lemon Sunshine

Tastes like lemon meringue pie in a chewy cookie. There are no flavorings in this one at all, only lemons, lemon peel and lemon oil, which is more work than it sounds and tastes like it.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, beet sugar, butter (MILK), EGG, lemon, lemon peel, lemon oil, lemongrass oil, lavender oil, aluminum free baking powder, citric acid, salt, plant based yellow color

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Reeses OREO Brownie

Reeses OREO Brownie

Inside: Reese's peanut butter and Oreo pieces.

Rich brownie dough packed with white chocolate bits and peanut butter wafers, stuffed with Reese's peanut butter and Oreo pieces, then topped with more Oreo. Two candies in one place, unsupervised.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, PEANUT butter wafers, butter (MILK), EGG, white chocolate chips(MILK,SOY), cocoa powder, OREO cookie pieces, vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, brown sugar

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “So very good! I definitely recommend! Wonderful treat!”

    Diann · Verified buyer

Dubai Peanut Butter

Inside out cookie homey haystack stuffed cookies

Inside: crispy peanut butter filling.

Our own idea, not a copy of anybody's. Honey butter dough with a hint of banana, filled with an extra big crispy peanut butter center. Same crackle as the Dubai one, different lane entirely.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SESAME, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

beet sugar, WHEAT flour, coarse oat flour, butter (MILK), honey, EGG, PEANUT butter, khataifi, MILK powder, butterscotch chips (MILK, SOY), SESAME paste, vanilla extract, sunflower lecithin, cinnamon, bananas, aluminum free baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Dubai Chocolate

Inside Out Cookie Dubai chocolate pistachio stuffed brownie cookies
+$1.00 premium flavor

Inside: homemade pistachio filling with crispy kataifi.

The viral pistachio bar, stuffed into a fudgy chocolate brownie cookie. Homemade pistachio filling with crispy kataifi, so it crackles when you bite it. Rich, nutty and unapologetically extra.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PISTACHIO, SESAME, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

sugar, chocolate, butter, WHEAT flour, semi-sweet chocolate chips (MILK, SOY), PISTACHIO, EGG, cocoa powder, white chocolate (MILK, SOY), Knafeh (shredded phylo, WHEAT) tahini (SESAME) vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Birthday Cake Funfetti

inside out cookie birthday cake funfetti

Inside: cream cheese frosting.

Buttery cake batter dough full of sprinkles, stuffed with a cream cheese frosting center. Birthdays happen once a year. This does not have to.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, butter (MILK), EGG, cream cheese (MILK), corn starch, powdered sugar, vanilla, cream of tartar, plant based rainbow sprinkles, aluminum free baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Gluten Dairy Friendly Oreo Stuffed Brownie

inside out cookie gluten/dairy friend oroe stuffed brownie cookies
Gluten friendly

Inside: a gluten-free Oreo.

A dark chocolate brownie cookie made with gluten friendly ingredients, and without dairy or eggs, stuffed with a gluten-free Oreo. Vegan, and not in a way anyone has to be brave about.

Gluten friendly, not certified gluten-free.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Every bag carries its ingredient label. If you have a food allergy, email info@insideoutcookie.com before you order and we will tell you exactly what is in this cookie and what else is in the kitchen. We answer fast.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “Very good! Tasty and rich Definitely recommend!”

    Diann · Verified buyer

Caramel Pumpkin Cheesecake Snickerdoodle

Caramel Pumpkin Cheesecake Snickerdoodle

Meet the fall cookie you didn’t know you needed! 🍂.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, brown sugar, butter (MILK), EGG, cream cheese (MILK), corn starch, xanthan gum, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves,allspice, black pepper

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Strawberry cheesecake stuffed cookie
Sold out

Inside: cheesecake filling and house-made strawberry preserves.

The snickerdoodle's louder sibling. A strawberry cookie base, cheesecake filling, our house-made strawberry preserves, and a pink strawberry crumble on top. It is like sprinkles, but with a job.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, butter, EGG, cream cheese, corn starch, powdered sugar, vanilla, cream of tartar, extract, strawberries, aluminum free baking powder, enzymes, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Ultimate Peanut Butter

Inside Out Cookie Ultimate Peanut Butter Stuffed Cookie

Inside: creamy peanut butter.

Browned butter peanut butter dough mixed with peanut butter chips, stuffed with peanut butter, topped with Nutter Butter pieces. Peanut butter, then more peanut butter, then a crunch on top.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, PEANUT butter wafers, butter(MILK), EGG,PEANUT butter(SOY), vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, brown sugar, Nutter Butter Cookies (WHEAT, SOY).

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “Amazing, huge, delicious cookies! I am so happy with my order!”

    Pam · Verified buyer

Protein Peanut Butter Stuffed Peanut Butter

Protein Peanut Butter Stuffed Peanut Butter
Sold out+$1.00 premium flavor

Inside: creamy peanut butter.

No chalk, no powder aftertaste, no lecture about macros. It is still a cookie and we are not going to pretend otherwise.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, PEANUT butter wafers, butter, EGG, rolled oats, cocoa butter, PEANUTS, molasses, rice protein,vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, pea protein, salt, brown sugar

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

BBC big beautiful chocolate

Inside Out Cookie chocolate stuffed chocolate brownie cookies

Inside: chocolate ganache.

A double brownie cookie packed with three kinds of chocolate chips and stuffed with chocolate ganache. If you have ever wanted a cookie to stop pretending it is a snack, this is the one.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

sugar, chocolate, MILK chocolate, dark chocolate, butter, WHEAT flour, semi-sweet chocolate chips (MILK, SOY), EGG, cocoa powder, Oreos, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, enzymes, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “S’mores cookie, BBC, and OG Chocolate Chip were phenomenal!! Snickerdoodle and strawberry tart were okay. Will reorder S’mores, BBC, and OG along with Peanut butter based in the future!!”

    Edwin · Verified buyer

Brookie Monster

Inside Out Cookie brookie monster stuffed cookie

Inside: a Reese's cup.

A chocolate chip cookie and a brownie fused into one object, stuffed with a Reese's cup and topped with M&Ms and Oreo crumble. Half brownie, zero manners.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PEANUT, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

sugar, chocolate chips (sugar, chocolate, cocoa butter, milkfat,SOY lecithin, natural flavor)butter, WHEAT flour, EGG, Reese’s Cup, M&Ms, cocoa powder, molasses,vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “I bought a load of cookies after seeing a content creator review them. This cookie is so rich! Right up my alley! Nice balance between chocolate and peanut better. Can’t wait to try the others!”

    Anthony · Verified buyer

Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

Caramel Stuffed Pecan Pie

Inside: homemade caramel.

Browned butter dough with roasted pecan pieces and a homemade caramel center. Pecan pie, rebuilt as a cookie.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, PECAN, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, brown sugar, butter (MILK), PECANS, EGG, vanilla extract, aluminum free corn starch, baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “So very good & enjoyed by the family.”

    Mary · Verified buyer
  • ★★★★★

    “The very bestest cookie ever!!”

    Anita · Verified buyer

Gluten dairy friendly Oreo stuffed chocolate chip

Inside Out Cookie oreo stuffed oreo cookie
Gluten friendly

Inside: a gluten-free Oreo.

A chocolate chip cookie made with gluten and dairy friendly ingredients, stuffed with a gluten-free Oreo and topped with more of it. It does not taste like a compromise, which is the only reason we bake it.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: COCONUT, EGG, SOY

Ingredients

GF Flour mix (Rice flour, tapioca starch, potato starch, xanthan gum, cassava flour) brown sugar, white sugar, dairy free chocolate chips(SOY), palm and coconut oil, EGG, apple sauce, Gluten Free Oreo Cookie, vanilla bean paste, aluminum free baking powder, salt, pea protein

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Gluten friendly, not certified gluten-free.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “Love this product. I will definitely order again. So good!”

    Matthew · Verified buyer

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

Oreo Stuffed Chocolate Chip

Inside: one whole Oreo.

Our browned butter chocolate chip dough with a whole Oreo hidden in the middle and more Oreo crumbled on top. A whole Oreo. Inside. Yes.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, brown sugar, chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) Oreo Cookie, butter (MILK) ,EGG, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Oatmeal Cream Pie

Inside Out Cookie oatmeal cream pie stuffed cookies

Inside: vanilla cream filling.

A soft browned butter oatmeal cookie with a creamy vanilla filling.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

sugar, WHEAT flour, butter, rolled oats, cream cheese(MILK), corn starch, confectioners sugar, EGG, vanilla extract, cinnamon, aluminum free baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Smore Cookie

Inside Out Cookie smores stuffed cookie

Inside: homemade marshmallow fluff.

A dark brown sugar honey graham cookie with chocolate pieces and milk chocolate chips, stuffed with homemade marshmallow fluff. Marshmallow, molten, no campfire, no smoke in your hair.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) butter (MILK) ,EGG, Graham Crackers (WHEAT), beef gelatin, corn syrup, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

Original Chocolate Chip

Original Chocolate Chip

Inside: no filling. This one is just cookie, done properly.

The one that started it. Browned butter dough, semi-sweet chips, dark and light chocolate wafers, baked slow so the middle stays soft.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, Semi-Sweet Chocolate chips (MILK, SOY), butter (MILK),EGG, cocoa butter, molasses, vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder, salt, coffee

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “The most amazing cookies I have ever tried!! Incredible!! My sister ordered a dozen!!”

    Timothy · Verified buyer

Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle

Cheesecake Stuffed Snickerdoodle

Inside: cheesecake filling.

Browned butter snickerdoodle dough rolled in cinnamon sugar, stuffed with a creamy cheesecake filling. It has been on the favorites shelf since the beginning and shows no interest in leaving.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, sugar, butter (MILK), EGG, cream cheese(MILK), corn starch, powdered sugar, vanilla, cream of tartar, cinnamon, aluminum free baking powder, salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “Wish I would have gotten more of this flavor!”

    Jessica · Verified buyer

Nutella Chocolate Chip

Nutella Chocolate Chip

Inside: Nutella.

Browned butter chocolate chip dough, semi-sweet chips, and a molten Nutella center.

Better warm: 15 to 20 seconds in the microwave, or 6 to 7 minutes at 350. Freezes for up to three months.

Ingredients and allergens

Contains: EGG, HAZELNUT, MILK, SOY, WHEAT

Ingredients

WHEAT flour, brown sugar, semi-sweet chocolate chips (MILK, SOY) butter (MILK), EGG, NUTELLA (HAZELNUT) vanilla extract, aluminum free baking powder salt

May also contain

Produced in a bakery that processes all known allergens.

Have a serious allergy? Email us before you order.

What people said about this one

  • ★★★★★

    “Are this cookie last night with milk bar cereal milk ice cream 5/5 great cookie”

    Anthony · Verified buyer

Your box

    Nothing in here yet. Tap + Add on any cookie.

    Switch to gluten friendly?

    Gluten friendly, not certified gluten-free.

    WHY THE MONEY IS BETTER SPENT HERE

    It's what's inside that counts

    Better ingredients make better dough
    • 01

      Made with real butter

      (Dairy free doughs aren't made with butter, obviously...)

    • 02

      Unbleached flour

      Clean, no extra BS.

    • 03

      No Funny Chemicals

      No preservatives.

    • 04

      Hand cracked fresh eggs

      Liquid eggs are gross.

    BAKED IN SPRING MILLS, PENNSYLVANIA

    The whole BS free list