What am I actually paying for?
A big cookie with the filling inside it, cut open on the site for your inspection. Made with real butter. Price by the box, no per-cookie math on this page.
YOU’VE ORDERED BEFORE
You already know. On a schedule it costs less.
don’t make me feel like a sucker.
Same box on a schedule: it costs less than buying once, ships free, and stops when you tell it to.
THE BOX
Twelve, on your rhythm or not.
Twelve stuffed cookies in a mix picked for you, and a duck. Buy it once, or put it on a schedule; the schedule costs less and ships free.
The box
$68.94$58.94Save $10.00$58.94Save $10.00
Ships free.
Subscribing renews automatically on the schedule you pick, at the price shown, until you cancel. We email you before every charge. Skip, pause or cancel any time in Subscriber HQ. Full terms
Damaged, melted or wrong? Send a photo. We replace it or refund it.
SHIPPING IS WORKED OUT AT CHECKOUT BY ADDRESS. SUBSCRIPTION BOXES SHIP FREE.
OR
Build your own mix.
Six, twelve, eighteen or twenty-four. Pick every flavor yourself, repeat a favorite, add the note.
Build your own mix
NOT READY FOR TWELVE
Start with six.
Six in a mix Nick picks. Same cookies, same duck.
The box$44.94
PROOF
Repeat buyers said it first.
- ★★★★★
“These cookies are delicious! I’ve tried them myself, and have sent them as gifts. Everyone absolutely loves them!”
Christi W. · Verified buyer - ★★★★★
“These cookies are AMAZING and worth every penny! They make great gifts and even better treats for myself!”
Timo B. · Verified buyer - ★★★★★
“The best cookies ever. Super yummy very fresh. Love love love”
Nanci · Monthly Cookie Box Subscription
WORD FOR WORD FROM YOTPO. ★ 4.8 AVERAGE ACROSS 359 REVIEWS.
THE HONEST MATH
Worth it, by the box.
Why subscribe instead of reordering?
The subscription price is lower than the one-time price on the same box, and it ships free. If you order most months, that’s the whole argument. If you order twice a year, buy the box and we won’t be offended.
Will I get stuck?
No. Skip a box, pause, cancel. All of it in your account under Subscriptions, no phone call, no retention maze. Cancel is a sibling of Skip, not hidden behind it. Flavor, size and schedule changes go by email.
Can I change the flavors?
Yes. Build your own mix, or ask for a swap from Subscriber HQ and Nick changes it by hand on the next uncharged box.
THREE QUESTIONS
Before you tap.
When am I charged?
On the schedule you picked. We email you before every charge.
If I subscribe, can I cancel?
Any time. Account, then Subscriptions, then Cancel. A few taps, no phone call. It stops before the next charge. Skip and pause live in the same place.
Does the subscription ship free?
Yes, subscription boxes ship free. One-time orders are quoted at checkout by address.
Not today? Take the list instead.
New flavors, the event schedule, golden duck sightings. No spam. We are certified.
