Is it chalky?
It’s a stuffed cookie with the filling cut open on the site for you to look at. We’re not going to describe a texture you haven’t tasted; the reviews below are from people who did, pasted unedited.
BURNED BY CHALKY BEFORE
A cookie first. Read the label second.
it’s a cookie. we’re not going to lecture you.
Ours is a stuffed cookie before it’s anything else, and every bag carries its ingredient label.
THE BOX
Twelve. Picked for you.
Twelve stuffed cookies in a mix picked for you, and a duck. Want the protein flavors in there? Build your own mix and pick them by name. The label on each bag says what’s in it.
The box
$68.94$58.94Save $10.00$58.94Save $10.00
Ships free.
Subscribing renews automatically on the schedule you pick, at the price shown, until you cancel. We email you before every charge. Skip, pause or cancel any time in Subscriber HQ. Full terms
Damaged, melted or wrong? Send a photo. We replace it or refund it.
SHIPPING IS WORKED OUT AT CHECKOUT BY ADDRESS. SUBSCRIPTION BOXES SHIP FREE.
OR
Build your own mix.
Six, twelve, eighteen or twenty-four. Pick every flavor yourself, repeat a favorite, add the note.
Build your own mix
NOT READY FOR TWELVE
Start with six.
Six in a mix Nick picks. Same cookies, same duck.
The box$44.94
PROOF
What people actually said about the cookie.
- ★★★★★
“This cookie is great! It has ingredients you can actually read and tastes homemade. Very creatively made with unique flavors, etc.”
Kristin M. · Verified buyer - ★★★★★
“You can tell these cookies were made with quality ingredients. The flavor of the cookie & fillings balanced perfectly.”
Ethan B. · Verified buyer - ★★★★★
“Shopped these cookies at a local home show and oh my! Spectacular flavor in each one! Try these cookies, you won’t be disappointed.”
Wanda D. · Protein Peanut Butter Stuffed Peanut Butter - ★★★★★
“The whole family loved them!”
Roxanne S. · Verified buyer
WORD FOR WORD FROM YOTPO. ★ 4.8 AVERAGE ACROSS 359 REVIEWS.
NO LECTURE, JUST THE LABEL
What we will and won’t say.
What’s in it?
Every bag carries its own ingredient label, and the protein cookies say exactly what the label says, no more.
Is it good for me?
It’s a cookie. We don’t make health claims, we don’t do the wellness voice, and we won’t tell you what it does for you. Read the label, decide for yourself. They don’t need heating, they’re just better warm.
Allergies?
Email the bakery before you order and we tell you exactly what’s in each cookie and what else is in the kitchen. We answer fast.
THREE QUESTIONS
Before you tap.
Where are the protein flavors?
In the lineup under protein cookies, cut in half like everything else. Pick them into any box from the builder.
How do I heat it?
Fifteen to twenty seconds in the microwave, or six to seven minutes in the oven at 350. It’s printed in the lid too.
How does it ship?
From Spring Mills, Pennsylvania, by UPS. Every cookie is baked and sealed each day in individual pouches. Shipping is worked out at checkout by address; subscription boxes ship free. Freezes for up to three months.
Not today? Take the list instead.
New flavors, the event schedule, golden duck sightings. No spam. We are certified.
